Published:Journal of Chromatographic Science,
ISSN 0021-9665 Volume 44,
Number 10, November/December 2006, pp.596-601
Enantioseparation of Chiral Organochlorines on
Permethylated b- and g-Cyclodextrin, as well as 1:1 Mixtures of
Them
Walter Vetter[1], Katja Lehnert[1], and Georg
Hottinger[2]
[1]Universität Hohenheim, Institut für Lebensmittelchemie,
D-70593 Stuttgart, Germany and
[2]BGB Analytik KG, Lettenstrasse 97, CH-8134 Adliswil, Switzerland
Gas chromatography columns coated with 10% permethylated
b- and g-cyclodextrin in 85% dimethyl–15% diphenyl polysiloxane
(b- and g-PMCD, respectively) and 1:1 mixures are prepared and
tested with regard to the enantioseparation of chiral chloropesticides.
On the columns with the individual O-methylated cyclodextrins
(O-tCDs), the enantiomers of aaeeee-hexachlorocyclohexane (a-HCH),
e-aeee-1,3,4,5,6-pentachlorocyclohex-1-ene (b-PCCH), and e-aaee-1,3,4,5,6-pentachlorocyclohex-1-ene
(g-PCCH), cis- and trans-chlordane, and cis-heptachlor epoxide
are separated on both columns, with the exception of the latter
being separated only on b-PMCD. On the column coated with 5% b-
and 5% g-PMCD, the resulting separation factor (a) is virtually
1/2 of the arithmetric mean of the elution-dependent separation
factors on the individual O-tCDs. In case of reversed elution
order on b- and g-PMCD, the enantiomers are not resolved on the
mixed columns as is the case with cis-chlordane. Likewise, the
lower resolution of the g-PCCH enantiomers on the mixed columns
prove the reversed elution order on b- and g-PMCD without having
enantioenriched standards available. On the column coated with
5% b- and 5% g-PMCD, similar retention times to those observed
on both 10% b-PMCD and 10% g-PMCD are obtained. On the column
coated with 10% b- and 10% g-PMCD, significantly longer retention
times are obtained compared with the columns that contain a total
of 10% chiral stationary phase (CSP). This indicates that a relevant
part of the interaction of the analytes with the chiral selector
is non-enantioselective and, thus, only delays the elution of
both enantiomers. Moreover, these non-enantioselective interactions
prevent a direct comparison of CSPs with different amounts of
the chiral selector. However, this is possible by using mixed
phases of two CSPs with similar properties. Using this system,
it is demonstrated that for the organochlorine compounds studied,
no higher separation factor is observed on the mixed CSPs than
on the individual O-tCD with the higher separation factor. Estimations
allow a prediction that enantioseparations of organohalogen compounds
can be achieved on columns coated with as little as 1% of the
CSP.
Reproduction
of editorial content of this journal is prohibited without publishers
permission.
This
article is available in its entirety by fax for $4.00 per
page.
Visa or MasterCard accepted.
To
order electronicallyclick here or call: 847-647-2900 ext. 1323 or fax request to: 847-647-1155.
Please
indicate JCS volume and issue along with
page numbers.